Man City vs Man Utd: The Scorelines, Scandals, and Showdowns You Forgot

The Man City vs Man Utd derby is more than a match—it’s a clash of histories, philosophies, and city pride.

From United’s early dominance to City’s Abu Dhabi-boosted rise, each meeting writes a new chapter.

Join BRG365 for an in-depth look at head-to-head records, unforgettable games, and what drives this enduring rivalry.

Rivalry Roots of Man City vs Man Utd

The Manchester Derby’s DNA is stitched into the city’s industrial past. Founded in 1878 as Newton Heath (railway workers), United embodied blue-collar grit, while City (1880, St. Mark’s church team) represented middle-class ambition.

Geographically split by six miles, Old Trafford and the Etihad became cultural fortresses—until 2008 changed everything.

City’s 2008 Abu Dhabi takeover reshaped the Man City vs Man Utd dynamic. Overnight, City gained financial firepower. 

Yet early derby results still favored United. Michael Owen’s 2009 last-gasp winner in a 4–3 thriller at Old Trafford showed United’s clutch mentality.

Before the buyout, United dominated derbies 28-19 since 1992; since 2008, City lead 35-28.Still, City’s heavy investment hinted that the balance would shift.

Premier League Head-to-Head

In the Premier League, the Manchester Derby has produced memorable moments and intense battles. 

As of April 2025, the two teams have met 56 times in the league, with Manchester United securing 26 victories, Manchester City winning 20, and 10 matches ending in draws.

Classic Clashes: Man City vs Man Utd

2011/12: City 6-1 United

Mario Balotelli’s "Why Always Me?" shirt summed up City’s swagger.

Two goals from the Italian, plus strikes from Aguero and Silva, embarrassed United on their home turf—the first 6-1 away win at Old Trafford since 1955. "This is the day the rivalry shifted," said The Guardian.

2009/10: United 4-3 City

With City leading 3-2, Michael Owen—signed after Carlos Tevez’s controversial move—slotted home in the 96th minute.

"I promised Fergie I’d deliver," Owen said. The goal kept United’s title hopes alive, while City’s "noisy neighbors" tag stuck for another season.

2011/12: Aguero’s 93:20

Trailing 2-1 to United, City needed a goal to snatch the title.

In the 93rd minute, Aguero fired home from Sergio Kompany’s knockdown, sending the Etihad into chaos.

Commentator Martin Tyler’s "Manchester is blue!" became the most-shared sports clip of the decade.

2022/23: City 6-3 United

Erling Haaland (3 goals) and Phil Foden (3) lit up the highest-scoring derby ever.

City’s 6-1 lead in the 84th minute showed their tactical dominance under Pep Guardiola. "This isn’t a rivalry; it’s a masterclass," said Gary Neville.

2024 FA Cup Final: United 2-1 City

Alejandro Garnacho (18) and Kobbie Mainoo (19) sealed United’s revenge for the 2023 final.

Ilkay Gundogan opened scoring, but United’s kids stunned Wembley—proof the rivalry’s next generation is as fierce as ever.

Read More: Crystal Palace’s FA Cup Final Dream: Ending a Decade of Final Heartache

Red vs Blue Stats

Tactical Shift: Since Pep Guardiola’s 2016 arrival, City average 61% possession in derbies, vs. United’s 44%.

United’s last league double? 2019/20 under Solskjaer.

Chants, Memes, and the 12th Man Battle

Fan passion is a defining feature of the Manchester Derby. 

At Old Trafford, Manchester United’s iconic chant “Glory Glory” has reached sound levels of 115dB, while Manchester City’s “Blue Moon,” once accompanied by fireworks in 2018, registered a staggering 122dB—loud enough to shatter three stadium windows.

The rivalry extends to social media, where creativity runs wild.

After City’s 6–1 thrashing of United, fans turned Red Devils players into “Where’s Wally?” memes.

In return, United supporters fired back following the 2024 FA Cup win with jabs like, “City’s treble? More like treble losses.”

Even the city itself plays along. The Piccadilly Lights, one of Manchester’s urban landmarks, switch colors after each derby—red for United victories and blue when City wins.

Read More: Leicester City Standings: The 2016 Miracle and Rivalry with Manchester United

Local Feud Turned Worldwide Spectacle

The Manchester Derby is no longer just a local clash—it’s a global football event.

The 2023 FA Cup final between the two clubs attracted an audience of over 600 million viewers and generated £120 million in sponsorship revenue.

Since the 2008 takeover, City’s market value has skyrocketed from £310 million to £4.7 billion by 2024.

The cultural impact is equally massive. Documentaries like Blue Moon Rising (City) and Red Devils (United) have collectively surpassed 100 million views on YouTube.

Meanwhile, fan-made anthems—such as City’s remix of “We Are the Champions”—have been streamed over 50 million times worldwide.

The next chapter of Man City vs Man Utd will feature new stars—City’s rising midfielders and United’s academy graduates.

 As City chase a ninth title and United aim to reclaim glory, each derby will carry fresh significance.

One thing is certain: in Manchester, red or blue, the derby will always ignite passion.

Also Read: Man United vs. Man City history, head to head: All-time records, matchups, Premier League results in Manchester derby